Amazon Advertising Maturity Model – Roadmap To Success


Intentwise Amazon Advertising Maturity Model

Amazon advertising is a hyper-competitive space for brands and manufacturers, and it’s only intensifying. The companies that will be most successful are those that invest early on in the processes, tools, and expertise necessary to build a sustainable advantage. 

To get ahead on Amazon, you need a series of sophisticated SOPs (Standard Operating Procedures) for your Amazon ads system.

Companies need to be asking themselves:

  • Are teams learning quickly enough and keeping pace with Amazon’s changes?
  • Is all the critical data easily accessible and are we extracting value from it?
  • Are teams putting their time to the best use?
  • What are the right investments to stay competitive?

If you want to get ahead on Amazon, it is imperative that you make a strategic playbook for your growth.

At Intentwise, we built an Amazon Advertising Maturity Model in order to lay out a roadmap to success. We have broken down the work into three different stages: Explore, Scale, and Lead. 

We identified the key opportunities in each stage, and the actions you should be taking to propel your brand forward.

Intentwise Amazon Advertising Maturity Model

Stage 1

EXPLORE: Testing the Amazon waters

 In this initial stage, brands are just getting started with Amazon PPC ads. The primary goal is to test the waters and see what type of results can be achieved with this advertising channel.

Campaigns are small-scale and have modest monthly budgets. They can be managed manually, using the reporting that the Amazon platform offers.

Key Opportunities & Actions:

Most brands getting started with Amazon advertising don’t yet have extensive knowledge about the platform and its dynamics. Testing the waters provides an excellent opportunity to deepen internal expertise and to foster a culture of continuous learning, especially since Amazon is constantly releasing new capabilities.

It is also imperative at this stage to ensure consistency and excellence in the execution of your campaigns. Anything less will distort your understanding of the platform’s potential for your brand. To mitigate this risk, we highly recommend engaging an expert to conduct an audit of your performance. An expert’s assessment can help improve execution, elevate your internal expertise, and get you ready to scale even faster.

Stage 2

SCALE: Automating insights from your data

As budgets grow and campaigns are increasingly sophisticated, brands enter the second stage. By now, they will likely have a dedicated person or an external consultant/agency managing their PPC ad execution.

At this stage, many routine campaign management tasks, such as bid updates, new keyword additions, and performance monitoring are semi-automated through pre-defined rules. The team is able to dig deeper into performance data using rich segmentation tactics, such as analyzing performance by product categories, brand versus non-brand keywords and new versus existing products. This level of sophistication allows your team to rapidly diagnose problems and identify solutions.

Eventually, you might look into other tools, such as leaning on an AI-based bid management system to change your bids for at least some of your campaigns. You should also begin to explore upper-funnel ad formats, like DSP, that go beyond the standard sponsored ads. 

Lastly, you could begin to automate other parts of your business—for instance, when it comes to analyzing your customer reviews. For example: You could upload a file of all of your reviews into a Large Language Model (LLM) like ChatGPT, and receive an AI-generated summary of common complaints or talking points across the reviews. Mixing in tools like ChatGPT and other AI Amazon ads tools is an important way to streamline your Amazon SOP. 

Key Opportunities & Actions:

To stay competitive at this stage, brands must shift where they spend the bulk of their time from tactical execution to strategic analysis. This requires investing in automation on multiple fronts, including performance monitoring, bid management, and keyword optimization. Automated alerting can help detect performance anomalies rapidly.

Automated bidding rules or AI-based bid management can help brands execute sophisticated Amazon PPC scenarios, such as bid changes by day-of-week and time-of-day, without much effort. In the case of AI-based bid management, you can also anticipate when your ACOS doesn’t follow a linear path: sometimes, to improve your ACOS, the best approach is not to bid, but to bid up.

From a learning and development standpoint, the most successful brands at this stage are working to build their team’s expertise on two fronts simultaneously: Amazon advertising best practices and data analytics.

Brands must rapidly learn from advertising data and other market place signals such as organic ranking, price changes, content quality, customer reviews, overall sales and more. In order to accomplish this, brands must have a seamless strategy for collecting, analyzing and acting on these disparate data sets.

Stage 3

LEAD: Experimenting, learning, and adapting rapidly

Brands at this stage are the dominant players in their respective categories. What differentiates these brands is their willingness to experiment, fail quickly, learn from it, and start all over again. Their goal is to do what it takes to find out what works for them as quickly as possible.

Brands have advanced analytical capabilities with which they can extract significant value from their data assets. They are able to pose complex questions, answer them, and execute their advertising dollars efficiently.

Examples of such questions include:

  • What is the true incremental effect of advertising spend on sales?
  • How sensitive are sales to ad spend in each product category?
  • What is the impact of price changes on advertising ROI?

As Amazon introduces new capabilities, these brands are at the forefront of testing and leveraging these capabilities to their advantage before others do. They are becoming proficient in powerful new tools like Amazon Marketing Cloud, which allows them to track Customer Life-Time Value (CLTV), New-To-Brand metrics for Sponsored Products ads, multi-touch ad attribution, and much more.  

In summary, brands that win on Amazon are nimble, they take calculated risks, they are constantly experimenting and are trying to unlock value from every available signal / data set.

Key Opportunities & Actions:

Brands must go beyond rule-based automation to having much of their performance diagnostics and campaign execution driven by machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) algorithms. ML/AI algorithms can learn from data and make predictions/decisions at scale. ML/AI have been around for a very long time. What has changed in the recent past is that cloud computing developments have made ML/AI capabilities very accessible. Brands that embrace these capabilities in solving the hard problems specific to their business will have a significant competitive advantage.

Fostering a culture that embraces experimentation, failing fast and learning fast, will also help push a brand to the top and keep it there. To do this, you must:

#1. Collect as much data on as many variables as possible: advertising, pricing, organic ranking, content, reviews, sales, etc.

#2. Have a disciplined process to do the following:

  • Ask high impact questions on a regular basis
  • Analyze information and frame responses to the above questions (hypotheses). Leverage machine learning / AI capabilities where appropriate
  • Test the hypotheses and operationalize successes

#3. Ensure that both the data scientists and business experts are working in close collaboration. This collaboration is critical to finding big wins quickly.

Amazon’s rapid ascent as an advertising powerhouse presents a major opportunity for brands and manufacturers. With the right vision, plan, and investment, Amazon advertising channel can serve as a sustainable strategic advantage.

Connect with us to learn more about where you stand on this maturity curve and how to accelerate your growth.

(Want more insights like this? Don’t forget to subscribe to our newsletter.)


Subscribe to our Newsletter​

Learn about product updates, webinars, and news for ecommerce professionals.